Competition results

COMPETITION RESULTS

Monday, 7th of September 2020, 12:00 a.m. Romanian Time Zone

Cluj Arena, 2nd floor, Multimedia Hall (Aleea Stadionului nr. 2, Cluj-Napoca, Romania)

Between the 3rd and the 6th of September 2020 the competition jury has debated and decided the results for the „Cluj-Napoca Comprehensive Transplant Centre” International Design Competition, competition officially launched on the 28th of May 2020. The Contracting Authority is the Cluj County, the owner of the land and the beneficiary of the competition results. The competition was organized by the Order of Architects in Romania (OAR) in partnership with the Transilvania Office of the Order of Architects in Romania (OAR-T).

On Monday the 7th of September 2020, at 12:00 (GMT+3), the competition results were announced at the Cluj Arena (Aleea Stadionului nr. 2, Cluj-Napoca). The event was broadcasted through a live video on the OAR Concursuri Facebook page (https://www.facebook.com/oar.concursuri/).

AWARDED PRIZES

1ST PRIZE: The design services contract  with an

estimated value of 3.248.500 EUR, exclusive of VAT      

2ND PRIZE:  60.000 EUR

3RD PRIZE: 30.000 EUR

1ST MENTION: 5.000 EUR

2ND MENTION: 5.000 EUR

 

The winning projects are as follows:

1ST PRIZE – PROJECT NO. 79 – MO7823 – PINEARQ S.L.P. ASSOCIATED WITH DICO SI TIGANAS BIROU DE PROIECTARE S.R.L 

Board 1

 

Board 2

 

Board 3

 

Board 4

 

Board 5

 

Main authors: Arh. Alberto de Pineda Álvarez

Coauthors: arh. Jenica Craiu, arh. Alexandra Demetriu, arh. Serban Tiganas, arh. Alexandrina Kiss

Architecture collaborators: arh. Giovanna Pomo, arh. Bogdan Dragomir, arh. Maria Buiga 

”The project proposes a highly professional and apparently effortless integration of all requirements of the design brief and as well as an appropriate response to the difficult site, creating a positive transition from the heterogeneous urban surroundings towards the green core of the historic site of The University Clinics.

The jury commends the excellent achievements of this project in terms of putting the patient at the core of its conceptual approach, and creating a positive atmosphere, to alleviate the stress that patients are subjected to during the transplant process. The design is clearly expressing these attributes and gives an honest account of the programme.” – Jury feedback

2ND PRIZE – PROJECT NO. 63 – AC1050 – ASIZA BIROU DE ARHITECTURĂ SRL 

Board 1

 

Board 2

 

Board 3

 

Board 4

 

Board 5

 

Main authors: arh. Vlad Sebastian Rusu, arh. Octav Silviu Olănescu, arh. Anamaria Olănescu, arh. Miruna Moldovan

Architecture collaborators: arh. Ștefania Boca, arh. Petrică Maier-Drăgan, arh. Andrada Pinte

Specialties collaborators:

Structură de rezistență – ing. Ovidiu Rusu

Fluide medicale, inginerie medicală, epidemiologie, instalații – ing. Istvan Besenyei, ing. Cornel Rusu 

”The project proposes a low-rise composition of simple volumes, seamlessly integrated into the existing built fabric of the listed ensemble of The University Clinics, and considerate about the urban surroundings. The rational, calm and discreet atmosphere and the quality of the architectural solutions match the function of the building and of the entire ensemble. – Jury feedback

3RD PRIZE – PROJECT NO. 82 – SH0607 – STARH – ARHITECTURA, CONSTRUCTII, DESIGN SRL. 

Board 1

 

Board 2

 

Board 3

 

Board 4

 

Board 5

 

Main authors: MARIA-IULIA STANCIU, FLORIAN STANCIU

Coauthors: COSMIN GĂLĂȚIANU, COSMIN VALENTIN GEORGESCU, OCTAVIAN BÎRSAN, CRISTIAN ALEXANDRU BEȘLIU, CEZARA LORENȚ, OANA GRĂMADĂ, ROBERTA FURMUȘELU, EDUARD UNTARU

Architecture collaborators: NELA ANDRIEȘ, ANA CĂTĂLINA MUȘETESCU

Specialties collaborator: Ing. KISS KRISTIAN 

”The proposal presents a complex and multilayered project, a rich story of a world apart, which can be read on multiple levels. While showing a refined understanding of the historical and cultural background, and a set of subtle references to the University Hospital Complex, it is a very contemporary architectural gesture, as it works in an innovative way with attributes already validated by time.” – Jury feedback

1ST MENTION – PROJECT NO. 64 – PP1055  – PRÁCTICA ARQUITECTURA Y URBANISMO, S.L.P. ASSOCIATED WITH PLANHO CONSULTORES, S.L.P. 

Board 1

 

Board 2

 

Board 3

 

Board 4

 

Board 5

 

Main authors: PRÁCTICA ARQUITECTURA Y URBANISMO, S.L.P. & PLANHO CONSULTORES, S.L.P.

Architecture collaborators: Jaime Daroca, José Mayoral, José Ramón Sierra, Alonso Rosa, Amanda Castellano, Enrique Vallecillos Segovia, Manuel Pérez, Pablo Blázquez, Alfonso Fernández, Enrique Vallecillos Portillo 

”The project proposes a conspicuous response to the requirements of integration between the complex programme and the existing natural and built environment, relying on a contrasting dialogue of two clear volumes - a plinth and a prism - that perform distinct functional and architectural roles.” – Jury feedback

2ND MENTION – PROJECT NO. 70 – CR2020 – EXHIBIT ARHITECTURA SRL 

Board 1

 

Board 2

 

Board 3

 

Board 4

 

Board 5

 

Main authors: Oprea Dragoș

Coauthors: :  Bertleff Johannes, Oprea Cristian Mihai, Vlăsceanu Tudor Bogdan, Petrencu Nicolae, Cucoreanu Dana, Rășoiu Ciprian Ionuț, Szabolcs Egyed, Răzvan Andrei, Flavius Adrian Ianchiș, Nechita Sabina, Grecea Raluca, Bârsan Ioana Lucia

Architecture collaborators: Gavriliu Traian, Bucur Beatrice, Dimofte Alice, Necula Radu

Specialties collaborator: Dr. Angheloiu Bogdan 

”The jury appreciated the contemporary character of the intervention, which proposes a bold composition, mediating in a striking visual statement the complexity of the Victor Babeș street and The University Hospital Complex. By using clear composition principles and a contemporary expression, the project stands out for its volumetric accuracy and architectural quality.” – Jury feedback

 

The competition seeks to select the best design solution for a Comprehensive Transplant Centre, located in the central area of Cluj-Napoca Municipality, within the University Hospital Complex.

The ambition behind the competition is to design and execute the first transplant centre in the country that accommodates all the necessary facilities for four types of transplant: heart transplant, lung transplant, liver transplant and kidney transplant.

Moreover, the future Comprehensive Transplant Centre is to provide an example of good practices both in terms of medical architecture and with regard to the insertion of a volume of contemporary architecture in a historical, heterogeneous site.

The competition was organized in accordance with the Competition Rules of the International Union of Architects - UIA - and the provisions of the International Recommendations for Architecture and Urban Planning Competitions adopted at the General Conference of UNESCO of 1956, revised on 27 November 1978, in compliance with the provisions of the legislation in force regarding the award of public procurement contracts.

The Design Competition is a public, single-stage competition, open to Romania, all countries of the European Union, of the European Economic Area, and to the Swiss Confederation.

The design competition is organized as an independent procedure, in accordance with art. 105 letter a) of Law no. 98/2016 regarding public procurement, and subsequently, pursuant to provisions under art. 104 para. (7) of the same law, the design services contract is to be awarded to the winner of the competition, following a negotiation procedure without prior publication of a participation announcement.

COMPETITION JURY 

Full members:

  • Arch. Claudiu Salanță – CJ Cluj
  • MD Andrei Leșan
  • MD Peter Jaksch
  • Arch. Ștefan Bâlici
  • Arch. Oana Gavriliu - President of the Jury
  •  Arch. Andrei Șerbescu
  •  Arch. Silviu Aldea

Deputy members:

  • MD Alexandru Coman

The organizing team for the Order of Architects in Romania (OAR) is: arch. Ana Maria Zahariade – OAR Vicepresident for Competitions, arch. Mirona Crăciun – OAR Competitions Coordinator, arch. Ilinca Pop – Jury secretary, arch. Iulia Cucu – Competitions PR.

 

Details regarding the competition are available on the official website of the competition at:

www.oar.archi/en/concursuri/cluj-napoca-comprehensive-transplant-centre

 

The competition results are available at:

www.oar.archi/en/concursuri/rezultate/cluj-napoca-comprehensive-transplant-centre

All projects participating in the competition will be available starting with the 9th of September on-line under the “Entries” section of the competition website at:

www.oar.archi/en/concursuri/proiecte/cluj-napoca-comprehensive-transplant-centre

For live announcements and news please follow us on our competitions Facebook page (OAR Concursuri):

www.facebook.com/oar.concursuri/

Submit a question to the organizers

x_oar